MLB players’ union offers international signing plan, no draft


Jorge Castillo | ESPN

The MLB Players Association has proposed changes to the international amateur entry system, including a crackdown on illegal pre-agreements and incentives for small-market clubs, but not including an international draft that Major League Baseball is seeking in labor negotiations.

The MLBPA made the proposals during a bargaining session Friday — two days after Commissioner Rob Manfred insisted owners will not compromise on the salary cap and floor framework they’ve proposed. The union, meanwhile, has called a salary cap system a nonstarter. The stalemate is expected to lead to the owners locking out the players once the current collective bargaining agreement expires at 11:59 pm on Dec. 1.

Friday’s proposal called for stricter enforcement and greater punishment, including financial penalties and suspensions, for teams that engage in reaching verbal agreements with players before they’re eligible to sign at 16 years old. The MLBPA has argued the league could solve the problem by simply enforcing rules already on the books. Friday’s proposal enhanced those rules and penalties, and also specified that the union would be allowed to intervene when necessary to police the issue.

Those non-binding handshake deals, which are rampant in the Dominican Republic and Venezuela, are struck with children as young as 11 years old. They’ve led to widespread corruption, increased steroid use among youngsters hoping to impress scouts, and an uptick in falsified birth documents.

Reaching the deals as long as five years in advance has made teams less likely to honor them. Even when players develop as projected, teams withdraw due to medical concerns, lower signing bonuses or simply a change of plan, leaving the players scrambling to sign with a different for usually far less money. Those players and their families are often indebted to predatory loan sharks that take up to an additional 20% of a player’s eventual signing bonus on top of the 30% to 50% already owed to their trainers.

“We are committed to negotiating a system that preserves opportunities for future generations of players, protects young prospects from exploitation, and provides flexibility without further burdening international players with new artificial restrictions like a draft,” MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer said in a statement. “Our proposals help build upon baseball’s advances as an international game while safeguarding the interests of young athletes who are the future of our sport.”

MLB spokesperson Glen Caplin said the league made a concession Friday by withdrawing its proposal banning high school players from being eligible for the domestic amateur draft while proposing to maintain the current entry rules for domestic amateurs.

“On the international system, we continue to believe it is long past time to reform the system in ways that would address longstanding challenges and benefit future players,” Caplin said in a statement. “The enhanced transparency of the international draft that we have proposed best addresses the root causes of corruption in the current system.”

MLB has contended that the problem is too deep for a solution other than an international draft, which it says would produce the necessary unpredictability to eliminate the problems. The league’s draft, proposed in June, called for eligible players to be at least 18 years old (as opposed to 16 under the current system). It would consist of 12 hard-slotted rounds with an initial signing bonus pool totaling $200 million for the 360 players selected from outside the United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico.

The league also proposed an international draft when the last CBA expired five years ago. The current CBA was ratified in March, but the two sides set a July 25 deadline for the MLBPA to decide whether to trade the abolishment of the qualifying offer system, which has hampered major-league free agents’ earning potential on the open market, for the international draft. The union declined, and the qualifying offer system remained in place.

In addition to heightened enforcement and penalties, the union’s proposal Friday included allowing teams to roll over unused bonus pool space into subsequent signing periods and acquire bonus pool space for the following season. The flexibility, the union argues, would lead to less fixed future bonus pools, which would make it more difficult for teams to engage in pre-agreements.

The increased small-market incentives include increasing small-market clubs’ signing bonus pool by $1 million during a single signing period within the MLBPA’s five-year agreement, and by $500,000 for each signing period following a postseason experience; those clubs receiving increased signing bonus space for having lost or for having signed free agents or soon-to-be free agents; and those clubs receiving a financial reward for reaching the postseason, funded by the tax revenue collected from teams that exceed their signing bonus pool.